Preloading Stars Preloading Stars Preloading Stars Preloading Stars Preloading Stars

YOUR COMMENTS

Helen Childs

Can Fat Really Be Fit

by Helen Childs

We all know that as a group the "Lesbian Image" takes quite a battering from time to time. We are stereotyped often and unattractively as the checked shirt wearing, un-stylish, burn-our-bra-uber-feminists of urban legend. What a terrifying vision we must sound to those pre-pubescent hetero girls who are warned of a lonely GHD free fate by the cautious mothers of Middle England.

Anyone who has walked into a Lesbian Bar knows that this is untrue, and that in actual fact we are as much the slaves of fashion and the myths of what is considered to be "hot" as our gay male counterparts. This being the case I've recently become overly concerned with my own image, and more specifically the dreaded issue of weight!

Now that the summer is over there seems to be fewer and fewer reasons for me to be stropping around in just my bikini, not least because I live miles from a beach and it causes quite a stir at work. The truth of the matter is that I'm quite pleased about it. Constantly having so much flesh on show had been putting a lot of pressure on me to stay toned, and now it's getting chilly I can hear the distant call of the bakers, tempting me to stuff my face with pies, pasties and other traditional hip swelling English fayre.

The sight of me in a bikini is now very far removed from being worthy of a page 3 spread. Okay, perhaps I over exaggerate. I might make the centre-fold, but it would probably be a double page advert for Greggs. At any rate, my increasing proportions have given me pause for thought. As I see it I have two options. I can either take measures to return to my previous lithe svelte self, or I can continue to eat and drink my way up the fat laden ladder of dress sizes.

So, what do you think ladies? Should I conform to societal values of attractiveness? Should I allow how I view my body image and my self-esteem to be dictated by the media and generic Kate Moss types? Kate looks fabulous, it's true, but should we all want to be her clone? It has to be said that the media's view of the body beautiful may be an alluring one, but I would say that, because that's what we've all be programmed to think. Thin is attractive. Attractive is successful. Successful is happy. But are these things true? Magazines are all too quick to shoot down those people they spend their time hoisting onto pedestals in the first place.

But I digress, back to me! I, like everyone else am a sheep to conformity and incapable of independent thought, so last week I was determined to lose a little weight. Like us all, I've been guilty of spotting the slightly porky demographic in the population and shouting “Put the fork down!” (Just to clarify, I mostly only shout at documentaries on the television about obesity, not at unsuspecting passers by.) But I take it all back. I don't eat excessively, and so cutting back on things I enjoy (for that entire morning last week when I gave it a damn hard try) was like starving myself. I HATED it! I now almost have a new found respect for the tenacity and sheer single mindedness of the anorexics I know, though I am not promoting it as a healthy or viable alternative life choice.

The other option is naturally the "Big E"! I am not of course referring to doing so many class A substances that I forget to eat and dance off my puppy fat, but to that, my greatest fear (after clowns), Exercise! *Shudder* I tried ladies. I really really tried. And I'm sorry, but two hours in a room surrounded by focused grunting personal trainers and muscled women who looked and sounded like they were going into labour was enough to convince me that gyms are the Universe's way of telling me to get over it and just wear baggier clothes! Skin-tight lycra is clearly the last great leveller. It's a huge mistake for anyone to wear it, especially me, and I spent a good few hours trying to concentrate on moving around the room without bumping into any machinery as I didn't know where to look ... it was wall to wall camel toe. I was petrified.

These great revelations firmly in mind, I have made a fantastic discovery! If you like the recent craze for smock tops with an empire line they hide a multitude of sins (pies in my case), and make my breasts look huge. Strike! Equally, if you're feeling a bit more boyish, then shirts from Topman (I apologise for the brazen plug, but I have one and it really is HOT) do pretty much the same job. No muss, no fuss, no bother, and no me starving myself or flying backward through the air off a cross-trainer like a complete idiot! Simple.

Maybe we as a group need to all be a little less concerned with body image. I could do it alone, but just for once it would be nice not to be in the minority. If I'm honest I know that inside all of us there's a non-shallow all-inclusive lesbian screaming to get out, however cool and guarded we may act. My personal preference in women is rarely dictated by weight, and most of my friends agree. Strangely we all continue to be obsessed by being "thinner" because we perceive it to be more attractive. This is not always true. Whilst some may have a preference for slimmer types, we all know that when it comes to the crunch the most attractive traits in women are ones like confidence, intelligence and charm. I direct you to Exhibit A: Beth Ditto. I defy anyone who claims that they would discriminate against her on the basis of size. Yes she is a larger lady, but in every interview I've seen on the television she has utterly charmed the pants off me.

Perhaps what we could all do with (all women, not just lesbians) are more sexy yet large role models in the public eye. Strong successful women like The Ditto; like Amy Lame; like Sophie Dahl before she too caved to the pressure at the altar of "skinny", to show us all that to be slim can be attractive, but so can any size, so long as you're healthy and happy and have a beautiful attitude to match.

So, who'd like me to take them on a date then? I know an excellent chip shop, you can have anything you want, and we can stuff our faces on a park bench until we get huge. Okay, so I'm cheap as well as opinionated, but my thoughts on the evils of Capitalism is another article entirely!

How do you feel about how your body image, do you feel pressure to look a certain way?

Showing 20 out of (39) Comments

Posted by Ash, at 02:56 on Sat, Mar 1st

I think women in general are fit, I dont think in types, i think in colours and moods and surroundings and laughter and moments. Anyone can be fit, irrelevant of size, colour, etc etc,
lets face it ladies, whether its the freshly showered well prepared business woman, or the hot mechanic that come out covered in oil from under a car...BOTH are just as sexy, and generally you spend most of your time kissing their lips on their face (unless its a quick fumble) and so isnt it the facial features that attract the most...achne is probably my hardest thing to overcome. Anything other than that....im all good...

Posted by Archer, at 13:49 on Tue, Dec 18th

Iam extremely unattracted to skinny/thin girls, I have a mate who i think is a size 6?? and i musta turned her down a hundred times (which she hates because this is a girl who is never turned down!) i like my girls to have something to hold on to..and plus im scared of sleeping with skinny girls incase i break them lol! (im aware you cant but if their like a twig you cant help thinking about tht) it would be pretty hypocritical of me to say anything bad about following the crowd, as im currently trying to get thinner but unlike most girls im not trying to get skinny, just more toned, but i know what you mean about the gyms, and if you aint diverting your eyes you got huge muscle girls bullying u off machines, i went to a gym once i got the weight machine litrally lifted one weight and this big muscly girl came stood over me and coughed as if to say MOVE, then just leered at me, bloody hell! lol!, i say nothing wrong with a few extra pounds.

Posted by Julie Bateman, at 21:48 on Fri, Dec 14th

I am attracted to PEOPLE. People that are sexy, confident, funny and enjoy life. I am not attracted to or fit into any form of labelling ie. lesbian, bi, straight, fat, thin etc. Isn't it a more appealing quality to have the self confidence to enjoy who you are and also to enjoy discovering these qualities in others? Celebrate our differences and touch one another on a deeper level. Beauty is after all in the eye of the beholder!

Posted by hanley, at 13:25 on Sun, Dec 2nd

im only ever attracted to very thin girls, i dont think it is a conscous decision though, i dont think you can choose who youre attracted to any more than choosing to be gay or straight!

Posted by JP, at 18:19 on Sat, Nov 24th

Fat can definately be fit. i have thishuge crush on a larger girl. her size really doesnt make a difference!

Posted by Charlie, at 15:10 on Sun, Nov 18th

I know how you feel about size i always look at myself and think if only i had the will-power to lose some weight and then i think why should i i like who i am and thats all that matters (dont you agree?). I have recently become single and by going out confident and happy i dont have a problem pulling. So if you are happy with who you are then thats all that matters x

Posted by Em, at 21:55 on Thu, Nov 8th

Well myself i am far from a sheep, i do my own thing, dress my own way, hang out with people i find fun and interesting and really just do what i want. I dont believe in doing things just because it is seen as cool and popular. I mean why should we? isnt being unique and different better than being the same? wouldnt that make life a bit boring?
Now that is not saying i do not look after myself because i do believe that is also important. I enjoy staying healthy, fit and looking good. (not saying that it is wrong if you do not agree with me, we are all entitled to our own opinions) but as i am a athlete for my country, i do indeed work out, twice a day, six days a week. However i do not do it because people will think i'm cool or awesome doing it. I do it because i love sport and hope to bring home gold for GB in 2012. It really doesnt bother me what people think, i do it because i enjoy and love to do it and even if i was not a high standard athlete. I would still work out because i enjoy it and it refreshes me. Anyway girls as ive stated i think we should all do what we want, being unique is beautiful. It doesnt matter whats on the outside, it matters what type of person you are. By that i mean i am said to be very attractive and cute but also people say im very caring and fun loving and if i did not have those personal qualities. Then i would be worth nothing. I find girls for what they are not what they look like, sure you may find it attractive but if they have no personality, then that is a huge turn off, and can you say thats wrong ?
Hope you're all ok and having great days
Em

Posted by Hanzi, at 16:41 on Thu, Nov 8th

oh and btw, taryn, size 16 is fat? My jesus girl you must be the person who creates the sizes for highstreet shops. lol. You wouldn't date someone fat? Well lets hope they would never wanna date someone arrogant.

Posted by Hanzi, at 16:38 on Thu, Nov 8th

I think the fact that were discussing image in such a way makes whatever image choice were talking about irrelivent. "Is fat fit?" Not chaning anything just moving the goal posts on how to conform.

Personally, Im a big girl. Not the type like "Oooo I'm a 14/16!! Im huge!!" Proper big. And Of course I have issues about it, as much as any one who is really skinny has issues or someone who has a relatively big nose or whos left earlobe is slightly larger then the right... everyones got something, it's just different degrees. It's human nature to compaire and contrast, and while we do we will always worry that we don't quite fit in or add up.

So I think everyone should chill out n just pay attention to who ppl are, not what they are, coz marking one thing as "fit" is just another way of saying the opposite is "unfit", and thats just not nice.

Plus, you know that those who obsess over image n boast about how they look n all that shit only do it coz they know they basically got feck all else to offer someone, who'd wanna be like that??

Posted by katie, at 23:53 on Sun, Nov 4th

i am quite a small person compared to all my gay friends expect a few. but i have to say i dont mind wot size girls are yes there is a limit i guess but only in tht they r unhealthy. dont worry about ur self if ur happy thts all tht counts. Ignore every other person its up to u how u look jus dont let others make u feel bad for it. I have been with super slim girls and rather large girls and i think they r all great and super sexy in thier own way. x

Posted by Louie, at 01:45 on Sun, Nov 4th

ok i am a big gal and i find as long as i am healthy and active and dont just sit eating chocolate and actually make an effort to look and FEEL nice then i dnt think ive been discriminated! if people arent attracted to me that is their preference! as long as im happy i shud attract someone to me hopefully still looking for that lass but hey ho im only 18 still got time lol xxx

Posted by Erin, at 00:36 on Sun, Nov 4th

This is like an age old debate. Quite frankly, it seems to me that "slim" vs. "fat" is the new butch vs femme debate coming from a new angle. For years the gay community, who preaches tolerance and begs the wider community for an understanding of diversity, has had a traitor in it's ranks. The "preconceived notion" that people identify one way or another, and can be easily slotted into a nice little category for latter inspection.

Really, is it eer that easy? Fat can be fit... that was the question right? Being fat myself i can tell you my blood pressure is fine, as is my cholesterol. I play sports with my mates, and am known to kick arse and be way too competitive!

Maybe we as a community should just people by there moral or ethical stances rather than their appearances. Maybe we should practice what we preach and be accepting of diversity?

Posted by Sally, at 18:43 on Sat, Nov 3rd

Until very recently I have always had girlfriends who were tall and slim. That was until I met Sara. Sara is exactly the opposite. I don't think it matters what size you are. If we were all the same the world would be a very dull place.

Posted by taryn, at 14:43 on Sat, Nov 3rd

Im going to make myself unpopular here and say that I don't like fat women. My gf is a big women, size 16, but she's incredibly fit (in the sporty sense). In fact all of my gf's have been bigger than me, me being size 10-12, but they have also been in the gym every week and playing sport on weekends. Being big women didn't stop them being healthy and toned women. So no, I wouldn't date a fat woman. I don't like it when women aren't prepared to care for their bodies.

Posted by Emma, at 12:13 on Sat, Nov 3rd

It just so happens I was out at the local gaybar with two friends last night. We neither of us slim, but one of my friends is a very big girl which lead to some comment about cranes being needed to get her out of the place.

I find it incredibly sad that while we are used to being taunted for our size, we now have to cope with it from lesbian who should know how it feels to be abused and ridiculed for being in a minority. Although, if you listen to the papers, we are all actually getting fat now and slim is becoming the minority.

The young 17/18 year olds have the slight excuse of youth on their side. I just hope they realise in years to come exactly what they did, when they no longer have youth and beauty on their side. Let's hope they develop a personality instead of relying on their looks alone.

It's the women who are older that vex me. Surely by the time you reach your 40's you've seen more, learned more and have more brain smarts about you then to be supporting fattist comments, or even starting them yourself!

If you are a fit and active woman who works hard to look the way you look, there is absolutely nothing wrong with you wanting a similar body type. Truth be told, I don't find the very slim attractive at all yet no-body would call me slimmist. At the same time though, I wouldn't go around calling these girls twiglets, or telling them to go eat some pies or asking if they were anorexic or anything like that. I just ask that people have a bit of respect. It seems that insulting fat people is the last thing that has not been made an issue of. You can no longer make racial slurs, no longer discriminate against the sexes and homophobic comments will get you a reprimand. So why pick on the fatties?

Posted by leah, at 09:45 on Sat, Nov 3rd

i am a well proportioned size 22,with big boobs,shiney hair,good smile and im house trained ,popular,funny and smell nice. what more do women want?im not a fashion icon but how can i be at size 22.i dress well for my shape and im not afraid to fluant what i have .i think lesbians need to wise up and remember its not all about looks and what you wear. this could save women a lot of heart ache if relationships and first impresions were not built on looks alone !

Posted by lynzo, at 13:25 on Fri, Nov 2nd

well... im a comfy size 16- 18 depends on the labels... hmm. have been told by people to lose some weight and i'd be gorgous!!! which of course ment they were soon binned after... pisses me off when u get small minded women ... or yuck dare i say it men! lol. sayin oooh lynzo u have such a pretty face.... shame about the rest... have always been told to get down the gym even by my own father!!! i jus love chineses too much!!! damn u sweet an sour!!! haha. nar on a serious note i have a beautiful sized ten 18 yr old on my arm an im 26, i must be doin summat right when she cuddles into my back at the end of the day an says she loves my bumps an humps!!!!! lmao xx

Posted by Ana, at 11:52 on Fri, Nov 2nd

I'm a big girl and i love the way i look, i have never felt a presure to fit in or look a certain way, i have my own unique look and if ppl dont like it, tuff shit! i certainly dont go out of of my way 2 look good for small minded shallow lesbians, coz quite frankly they dont deserve my time, dont get me wrong i think it is a small minority that have this attitude but its outrageous. my close lesbian friends except all kinds of shapes and sizes which is why we are so close and get on so well, how dare ppl judge you on the outside. i am in a commited relationship and have had relationships in the past with some very attractive ladies who loved loved all abd every part of me, so the good guys do excist!!!

Posted by Elzan, at 09:09 on Fri, Nov 2nd

I'm a Lesbian, but I'm still a WOMAN!!!!
I really don't understand why gay girls want to have this butch look, yes you will get judged for it your a woman trying to look like a man! If I wanted someone who looks like a man why wouldend I rather take the real thing? Sorry to all the Butch girls out there but I'm a woman who likes the softer side of live and a girl who doesn't want to feel SEXY no matter if your straight of gay there must be something wrong. BIG can be Beautifull depends on how you dress!!

Posted by Rhianna, at 06:16 on Fri, Nov 2nd

9 time out of 10 I have no problem with my image and definitely don't feel a need to fill the shoes of what others may expect of myself or anyone for that matter.. I'm sure we all have days where we don't feel "quite right" or "adequate"; aside from those days I refuse to live up to another's silly expectations or definition of "image"... Myself... well I am a tiny person, but I have to be honest, I like my gals to have a bit of meat on them... Lady M. Monroe all the way!!!

xo

Rate It

Click on a star to submit your rating.

Rated 1Rated 2Rated 3Rated 4Rated 5Rated 6Rated 7Rated 8Rated 9Rated 10

Tell A Friend

* Required Fields



Your Friend's Email Addresses

Submit Comments

* Required Fields


Gay Girls - London Lesbians - Lesbian Forum